YouTube's New Video Player Redesign: Love It or Hate It? [Poll] (2025)

YouTube’s new video player redesign is here, and it’s already dividing opinions. Love it or hate it, this change is impossible to ignore. After months of testing, Google has officially rolled out the updated player across nearly every platform, and let’s just say, it’s a bold departure from what we’re used to. Given YouTube’s dominance in the long-form video space, this overhaul is bound to spark conversations—and maybe even a few heated debates.

But here’s where it gets controversial: When the redesign finally landed on my Google account earlier this week, my first reaction was… well, let’s just say it wasn’t love at first sight. As someone who’s always relied on theater mode for a more immersive viewing experience on my 32-inch monitor, the new UI felt jarringly oversized. The playback controls looked comically large, almost as if something had gone wrong during the update. And speaking of glitches, a screenshotting extension I use was visibly broken post-redesign, which didn’t exactly help my initial impression.

Even setting those technical hiccups aside, I’m struggling to warm up to this new look. The semi-translucent button borders are harder to spot, and the opaque white buttons themselves seem to take up more space than before. It’s a strange paradox—the redesign feels like it’s trying to minimize screen clutter while simultaneously expanding its footprint. On desktop, at least, it’s a visually messy experience that doesn’t quite hit the mark. Mobile users, however, might have a different story to tell, as the condensed layout seems to work better on smaller screens with curved edges.

And this is the part most people miss: While I’ve focused on the desktop drawbacks, it’s clear that not everyone shares my gripes. Comments on recent coverage suggest that mobile and TV users are far more forgiving of the changes. But let’s be honest—resistance to change is natural, and Google’s move here could very well split the audience right down the middle.

So, where do you stand? Are you team redesign, translucent buttons and all, or are you already nostalgic for the old layout? Here’s a thought-provoking question to chew on: Is this redesign a step forward in modernizing YouTube, or a misstep that prioritizes style over functionality? Share your thoughts in the comments, especially if you’ve noticed a difference across platforms like TVs, mobile, or desktop. Let’s keep the conversation going—because whether you love it or hate it, this redesign isn’t going anywhere anytime soon.

FTC: We use income-earning auto affiliate links. More. (https://9to5mac.com/about/#affiliate)